As part of my ongoing professional development, I make every effort to stay current on lesser-known rules that can impact retirees’ financial well-being. One such provision—often overlooked but important—is the “hold harmless” rule. Though rarely discussed, this rule plays a meaningful role in how Social Security and Medicare interact.
In this post, I’ll explain what the hold harmless rule is, who qualifies, and a commonly missed nuance that may affect individuals who delay Social Security benefits while already enrolled in Medicare.
What Is the Hold Harmless Rule?
The hold harmless rule is a federal provision that protects most Social Security recipients from seeing their net monthly benefit decrease due to increases in Medicare Part B premiums.
Here’s how it works: If your Medicare Part B premium is deducted directly from your Social Security benefit, your check can’t be reduced just because the premium increases. This helps ensure retirees don’t see their income contract due to rising healthcare costs.
Why This Rule Exists
Medicare Part B covers outpatient care, including doctor visits and preventive services. Its standard premium often rises annually due to inflation, increased healthcare costs, or policy changes.
Without the hold harmless rule, these rising premiums could reduce retirees’ take-home Social Security income. This provision offers a layer of protection and predictability, which is vital for retirement budgeting.
Who Qualifies?
You are eligible for hold harmless protection if all the following conditions apply:
- You are enrolled in Medicare Part B.
- You receive Social Security benefits or will be entitled to them for November and December of the current year.
- Your Part B premium is deducted directly from your Social Security benefit.
- You are not subject to income-related premium surcharges (IRMAA).
If you pay Part B premiums out of pocket—or if you owe IRMAA due to higher income—you do not qualify for this protection.
A Simple Example
Let’s say in 2025 you’re receiving $1,500/month in Social Security, and your Part B premium is $185, deducted directly from your benefit. Your net check is:
$1,500 – $185 = $1,315
Now, in 2026:
- The Part B premium increases by $10 (to $195).
- Your Social Security benefit increases by $5 (to $1,505).
Without the hold harmless rule, your net benefit would fall to:
$1,505 – $195 = $1,310 — a $5 decrease vs. last year.
But because of the rule, this can’t happen. Instead:
- Your benefit rises to $1,505.
- Your premium increases only by $5, matching the COLA, to $190.
- Your net benefit remains $1,315.
Key Points to Remember
While the hold harmless rule limits the impact of Medicare premium increases—it doesn’t prevent them entirely.
Once your Social Security benefits increase sufficiently (via future COLAs), Medicare may increase your Part B premium more than the standard annual increase, allowing the premium to “catch up” to the current annual increase. However, your net Social Security benefit will still never decrease year-over-year as a result, and there is no back billing for prior Medicare premium shortfalls.
A Common Pitfall: Delaying Social Security While on Medicare
Many retirees choose to delay claiming Social Security in order to receive a larger monthly benefit later. However, those who enroll in Medicare before claiming Social Security must pay their Part B premiums out of pocket—and during this period, they do not receive hold harmless protection.
As the authoritative retirement researcher Wade Pfau, Ph.D., notes in the Retirement Planning Guidebook, this becomes an issue primarily in years when COLAs are minimal or nonexistent. For example, someone who delayed Social Security until age 70 and turned 70 in 2019 would have paid about $550 more in total Medicare premiums over time compared to someone who claimed benefits at age 66 or earlier. While Pfau considers this a legislative flaw, he views it as a “slight knock” against delaying benefits—not a reason to avoid the strategy altogether.1
In Sum
The hold harmless rule may seem like a technicality, but it plays a significant role in protecting your income in retirement. If you’re receiving Social Security and have your Medicare premiums deducted directly from your check, you may be benefiting from this rule—whether you were aware of it or not.
1Wade Pfau, Retirement Planning Guidebook (Retirement Researcher Media, Inc., c. 2023), p. 216.
Abramson Financial Planning, LLC does not warrant the accuracy of the materials provided herein. Although the information provided is from sources which we believe to be reliable, we do not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information for any particular purpose. This information is for information purposes and does not constitute a recommendation for the purchase or sale of securities. Individual investment decisions should be made based on each investor’s financial condition, suitability, and risk tolerance. Investments may be volatile and can involve the loss of principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. Abramson Financial Planning’s employees may trade for their own accounts in any of the securities of issuers mentioned herein or in related investments. Abramson Financial Planning does not undertake to provide clients with tax, legal, or accounting advice, and clients are admonished to consult their own attorneys and accountants for determining the tax, legal, and accounting consequences of investments made on their behalf.